So Google released a redesign to their search engine. I got to be honest–I don’t like where they are going with this one. The idea behind it is that the new design makes it easier to access everything related to a search term, including social media, news, etc. But wait, weren’t all those options accessible from the top bar in the past? How is this change not redundant?
Furthermore, I know a lot of people use Google because the search results are not cluttered. It (was) mostly a bare page which I believe was one of Google’s high selling points. I want to be able to quickly get my search results, without being distracted by huge ad banners or mostly irrelevant videos and twitter feeds. This old bare search engine is quickly becoming a thing of the past– I’m seeing more and more ads that take up more and more space, videos, twitter streams, news streams, etc. If I wanted a left bar, I’d goto Yahoo.
Here is an excerpt from some of the more impassioned opinions from Google’s support forums.
In response to: “However, as would be expected to see in every organisation that matures, grows, acquires, earns, they have become over-confident in almost everything they do.”
“I think it’s the opposite. To me, everything that Google’s done seems to stem more from an inferiority complex if anything. The new You Tube layout begged, borrowed and stole elements from several other popular web sites (Digg, Metacafe). Now the new Google layout is modeled on Bing. This is quite shocking from a company that always prided itself on being a leader, not a follower. But that seems to be the prevailing trend now.
Google is feeling insecure, if not threatened by other internet entities. I don’t know why. But it’s written all over the new Metacafe/ Digg version of You Tube and Bing’s doppelganger. It didn’t need to be, but it is. The irony is that if it keeps revamping its brand to copy other ones, it’s going to lose competition to the very entities it’s afraid of.”
-hpstudios
To me, Google is adding clutter and it’s unnecessary. What do you think?